Decision Making: It’s not always the “rational” approach that is the best choice.

After a bit of a “hiatus,” I’m back with a few more blogs posts about DECISION MAKING.  Today, I share another interesting angle on the nature of decision making and how decisions are often made. 

Typically, we assume that making decisions should always be done using a rather straight-forward, logical approach: 

  • defining the problem or identifying the issue
  • gathering relevant information
  • determining possible solutions
  • choosing the best option
  • implementing the chosen action

According to management guru, Henry Mintzberg, sticking with that assumption in all decision-making situations (what he calls the “thinking first” approach) may be a mistake.  Mintzberg believes that utilizing a rational decision making process, as described above, is not as common as we believe. He even calls it a bit “mysterious” at times. Perhaps the world of decision making is not as clean and orderly as we think. 

He’s identified two other ways by which decisions are often made:

  1. Seeing First
  2. Doing First

The Seeing First and Doing First processes are must less rational and linear.  They value a creative, reiterative process to identify best solutions. 

Thinking First is best suited to problems where:

  1. The issue is clear.
  2. The data is coherent.
  3. The context is well-defined

Thinking First is most appropriate when companies are redesigning or re-engineering a production or service process.

Seeing First is best suited to problems where:

  • The issue is not clear and obvious and includes multiple elements.
  • Initial data may be confusing, complex, and emerge over multiple inquiries.
  • Solutions may appear as intuitive insights rather than the result of a rational process of inquiry.

This approach is most appropriate when companies plan to develop a new product or service for an emerging market.

Doing First is best suited to problems where:

  • The issue is unique and has unknown, confusing qualities.
  • It’s necessary to try several possible solutions, see what works, find out why, and then reject the others.
  • Often experimentation precedes “thinking first.”

This approach is most appropriate for companies facing a disruptive technology.

Mintzberg equates “Thinking First” with science; “Seeing First” with art; and “Doing First” with craft.”  It’s not necessary to abandon the “thinking first” approach all together.  Rather, the point of this discussion is to include the possibility of using all three in concert. 

He goes on to say that “…a company may tackle a new issues by craft [doing first], then to imagine by art [seeing first]; and finally in order to program by science [thinking first].  “Thinking First” should be used it when appropriate along with a seeing or doing first process if circumstances deem either as the best way to proceed.

So, don’t get stuck using only the narrow approach of “thinking first” when making decisions. Instead, consider the potential of also “Seeing First” and “Doing First.”

THINK, SEE, AND DO.

Jim Dittmar

Dr. James Dittmar is the Founder, President, and CEO of the 3Rivers Leadership Institute which began in 2014.  Prior to this Jim founded the award-winning Geneva College M.S. in Orprofessional pic single 4.25.17ganizational Leadership Program in 1995 and served as Chair of the Department of Leadership Studies and Director of the M.S. in Organizational Leadership Program until 2015. He is Professor Emeritus from Geneva College.Should you have any questions, comments or feedback, please contact him at jimdittmar@jimdittmar.com


One thought on “Decision Making: It’s not always the “rational” approach that is the best choice.

  1. Great topic, Jim! I’m involved with 2 brand new ministerial organizations and the decision making style will vary depending upon leadership’s understanding various personalities of the team members. We have, however, already applied one SWOT analysis. I’ll keep you posted! Connie Shroyer

    Like

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s